Diversification is often described as the only free lunch in investing. That’s true, up to a point.

If you don’t fully understand what you own, diversification isn’t just useful, it’s essential. It protects you from your blind spots: wrong assumptions about business quality, hidden balance sheet risks, management missteps, valuation traps, and macro shocks you didn’t model. In that context, spreading your capital across more names lowers the chance that one mistake causes permanent damage.

But diversification is mainly a defensive tool. It lowers the cost of being wrong. It does much less to help you profit from being right.

That’s where concentration comes in.

When you really understand a company (its unit economics, its moat, how management is paid, how it spends its cash, what it’s worth and what could go wrong), you can afford to size it by conviction instead of spreading money evenly. If your best idea has the same weight as your 12th-best idea, your edge gets diluted.

If every position gets the same weight, you’re treating every idea as equally good. They almost never are.

I find it helps to think in two buckets:

  1. Uncertain positions (protect with diversification): names you like but haven’t fully stress-tested.
  2. High-conviction positions (express with concentration): names where you’ve done the work and can explain the thesis in a few clear, falsifiable points.

This is why some disciplined investors allow their top 3 to 4 positions to represent roughly 50% of the portfolio. That isn’t reckless if it’s deliberate. It says: “I want real exposure to my best ideas, with enough other holdings to survive a surprise.”

Concentration without rules is just gambling, though. These are the ones I’d want in place:

  • A clear thesis: what must happen for the investment to work.
  • A disconfirming checklist: what evidence would prove you wrong.
  • Position caps: even your best idea gets a maximum size.
  • Liquidity awareness: don’t build a position you can’t responsibly exit.
  • Ongoing review cadence: conviction should be updated by new facts, not anchored to purchase price.

There’s a psychological upside too. A portfolio with too many names turns into busywork: lots of tickers, not much depth, and constant monitoring. A focused core forces you to think harder, because you can’t hide behind averages when every position matters.

So it isn’t about picking a side. It’s about matching how concentrated you are to how well you understand what you own:

  • Early in research: diversify.
  • As knowledge and conviction increase: concentrate selectively.
  • If thesis quality deteriorates: de-concentrate quickly.

Diversification is an honest admission of what you don’t know. Concentration is what you do with what you’ve earned the right to believe.

The investors who beat the market over long stretches usually aren’t the ones with the most positions. They’re the ones who know exactly why they own each one, and size it to match.