I went through a batch of Canadian-listed single-stock income products from providers like Purpose, Harvest and Ninepoint, ranked them by their headline monthly yield, and checked how their prices have done since launch.
The short version:
- Some yields are very high (often 10%–30%+).
- High yield does not mean high total return.
- In several cases, unit price dropped materially since inception, which can offset distribution income.
If you’re looking at these, judge them on yield, price trend, the quality of the underlying stock and how the strategy works, all together.
Snapshot Highlights
The table below summarizes selected entries with the highest displayed yields in that snapshot.
| Ticker | Underlying | Inception Price | Current Price | Price Change | Distribution / Month | Shown Yield |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SHPY | Shopify | $10.00 | $7.87 | -$2.13 | $0.2200 | 33.55% |
| SHPE | Shopify | $12.00 | $9.31 | -$2.69 | $0.2500 | 32.22% |
| SHHI | Shopify | $10.00 | $7.72 | -$2.28 | $0.1800 | 27.98% |
| CCOE | Cameco | $12.00 | $17.80 | +$5.80 | $0.3700 | 24.94% |
| AEME | Agnico Eagle | $12.00 | $17.86 | +$5.86 | $0.3500 | 23.52% |
| KGHI | Kinross Gold | $10.00 | $10.27 | +$0.27 | $0.2000 | 23.37% |
| CLHI | Celestica | $10.00 | $11.18 | +$1.18 | $0.2100 | 22.54% |
| CCHI | Cameco | $10.00 | $14.63 | +$4.63 | $0.2700 | 22.15% |
| ABHI | Barrick | $10.00 | $15.64 | +$5.64 | $0.2600 | 19.95% |
| TY | Telus | $10.00 | $6.57 | -$3.43 | $0.1000 | 18.26% |
What This Data Is Telling Us
1) The same underlying can produce very different outcomes
Shopify-linked products show very high payout rates in this screen, but also notable price drawdowns from inception. Meanwhile, certain commodity-linked names (like Cameco and gold miners) show both strong payouts and positive price changes in the same period.
Lesson: product structure and entry timing matter as much as the underlying ticker.
2) Yield can spike when price falls
Most of the “yield” figures on these products are calculated from the current market price. If price drops and payout is unchanged, displayed yield mechanically rises.
That can make the headline number look better while total return gets worse.
3) Sector leadership drives the scoreboard
In this screen, miners/energy names generally held up better than telecom and some consumer names. If sector momentum changes, this ranking can also change quickly.
Risk Checklist Before You Buy
Use this quick checklist before allocating capital to high-yield single-stock products:
- Read distribution policy: Is payout fixed, variable, or formula-based?
- Understand option overlay: Covered-call intensity can cap upside.
- Check NAV trend: Long-term NAV erosion can offset income.
- Compare total return: Benchmark against just owning the stock/ETF.
- Tax treatment: Distribution character (income, ROC, capital gains) matters.
- Concentration risk: Single-name products are not diversified.
A Practical Way to Use These Products
For most investors, I think a sensible approach is:
- Keep these products as a satellite income sleeve (smaller % of portfolio).
- Pair with core diversified holdings for long-term compounding.
- Reassess positions quarterly using total return, not yield alone.
Bottom Line
A big monthly payout is nice, but it’s only half the story. Before you buy, ask whether the income can last, what the price has been doing, and how much you’re betting on a single stock.